Machinery comparison

Coriolis vs magnetic flowmeter filling

Compare Coriolis mass-flow and magnetic volumetric-flow filling for conductivity, density, accuracy, pressure loss and cleaning.

Production environment relevant to coriolis vs magnetic flowmeter filling

Quick answer

A Coriolis meter measures mass flow and can also provide density information, making it useful where mass is the control quantity or density varies. A magnetic meter measures volumetric flow of electrically conductive liquids with an unobstructed bore. Product conductivity, bubbles, required quantity and installation conditions decide the route.

Side-by-side comparison

Decision factorCoriolis mass flowmeterMagnetic flowmeter
Measured quantityMass flow; density may also be availableVolumetric flow
Product requirementBroad liquid range; two-phase flow still problematicLiquid must meet conductivity requirement
Internal pathCurved or straight tubes depending designTypically full-bore lined measuring tube
Density changesMass result is not inferred from fixed densityMass requires separate controlled density conversion
Pressure lossDepends on tube geometry and sizeOften low with correctly sized full bore
BubblesCan disrupt measurement and repeatabilityAir can reduce effective filled pipe and accuracy
CleaningAssess tube geometry, drainability and materialsAssess liner, electrodes, drainability and velocity
Cost and sizeOften higher cost and weightCan be economical for suitable conductive liquids

Decision checks

  • Declared quantity is mass or volume
  • Minimum product conductivity
  • Density and temperature variation
  • Entrained air and foam risk
  • Minimum and maximum flow rate
  • Pressure drop and supply system
  • Wetted materials, cleaning and drainability

How to prove the choice

Use the production formulation at temperature extremes and include start-up, supply-level change and bubbles. Compare meter zero stability, repeatability, cut-off and cleaning recovery with the intended valve and nozzle.

Relevant specialist route

Automatic Filling Machines

Automatic filling systems selected by measurement principle, product and container.

View the solutionautomaticfillingmachines.co.uk
Selection note: Do not select from a comparison table alone. Test representative product and packaging against a written acceptance plan.
Comparison questions

Questions customers also ask

Can a magnetic flowmeter measure oil?

Most oils have low conductivity and are generally unsuitable for magnetic measurement; confirm the actual formulation with the meter supplier.

Does Coriolis measurement eliminate density control?

It measures mass directly, but product condition and two-phase flow can still affect the filling system and pack result.

Which meter has lower pressure drop?

It depends on size and design; a full-bore magnetic meter can be low-loss, while Coriolis tube geometry must be checked.

Can either meter handle foam?

Entrained gas can disrupt both systems. Control aeration and trial the real process conditions.

Ask a question